Photo: Mathew Coulton / Pexels
Summer brings increased outdoor activity for dogs—hiking, swimming, fetch, and long playtime mean your pup needs proper nutrition and mental stimulation during hot months. But the treat aisle has expanded significantly, and not all options deliver the same nutritional value or behavioral benefits.
This guide compares three distinct treat categories: traditional regular treats, natural dog treats with moderate protein, and protein-packed chews designed for active dogs. We'll examine what makes each option different, who they're actually best for, and how to read ingredient labels to spot quality differences that matter for your dog's digestion and energy levels.
Before purchasing natural dog treats, verify the protein source listed in the ingredients and check the guaranteed analysis on the label to ensure the protein percentage meets your dog's dietary needs, as "natural" claims don't guarantee high protein content or quality protein sources.
Conventional dog treats designed primarily for taste and enjoyment, these typically prioritize palatability over nutritional density. Most contain higher carbohydrate and fat content relative to protein, with filler ingredients and artificial preservatives that offer minimal health benefits. Regular treats are fine for occasional training rewards or quick entertainment but shouldn't constitute a significant portion of your dog's daily caloric intake.
Best for: Occasional training rewards, behavioral incentives, and dogs with no specific dietary or activity requirements
These treats use real, wholesome ingredients without artificial additives or fillers, but don't specifically emphasize protein content. Natural treats provide essential proteins, vitamins, and minerals in a cleaner formulation than regular treats. They're particularly valuable during summer when dogs are more active, as they support energy replenishment without synthetic preservatives that can upset digestive systems or cause allergic reactions in sensitive dogs.
Best for: Health-conscious pet owners seeking ingredient transparency, dogs with sensitive stomachs, and summer outdoor adventures requiring sustained energy
Designed specifically for active dogs, these chews prioritize protein content and concentrate nutrients into a long-lasting format. Quality protein-packed chews list named meat sources (chicken, beef, fish) as the first ingredient rather than vague terms like 'meat meal' or 'by-products,' indicating higher bioavailability and digestibility. These chews serve dual purposes: mental stimulation during peak heat hours when outdoor activity should be limited, plus muscle maintenance support for dogs spending time hiking, swimming, or playing intensively.
Best for: Active summer dogs, muscle development support, extended mental stimulation during hot afternoons, and training-focused owners
The right choice depends on your dog's activity level and your primary goal. Regular treats remain practical for frequent training sessions where you need low-calorie, quick rewards. Natural dog treats strike a middle ground for pet owners prioritizing ingredient quality and digestive health without specialized fitness goals. Protein-packed chews (like Gnarly Pet's offerings) emerge as the superior choice specifically for active summer dogs that spend significant time outdoors hiking, swimming, or playing intensively. The key differentiator: check whether the first ingredient is a named meat source (chicken, beef, fish) rather than 'meat meal' or by-products. This single detail predicts digestibility and bioavailability better than marketing claims. For summer specifically, protein-packed chews justify their higher cost by supporting muscle maintenance during peak activity months while providing the extended mental stimulation that matters during hot afternoon hours when outdoor play must be limited.
Natural treats emphasize ingredient quality and the absence of artificial additives, while protein-packed chews emphasize nutritional concentration and high protein percentages. A natural treat might contain real chicken and vegetables but offer moderate protein levels. A protein-packed chew prioritizes protein content first and uses concentrated formats (like jerky or dense chews) for longer-lasting satisfaction. Both can be natural, but protein-packed varieties specifically target active dogs needing muscle support.
Look at the ingredient list order. The first ingredient should be a specific meat (chicken, beef, fish, turkey) rather than generic terms like 'meat meal,' 'by-products,' or 'meat by-products.' Named meat sources are more bioavailable for dogs' digestive systems. Vague terminology usually indicates lower-quality, harder-to-digest protein sources that may cause digestive upset.
For active summer dogs—especially those hiking, swimming, or playing intensively—yes. The concentrated protein supports muscle maintenance, and the longer-lasting format provides extended mental stimulation relative to regular treats. For dogs with light activity levels or those used primarily for training rewards, moderate natural treats offer better value. Consider your dog's summer activity level and primary purpose for treats when deciding.
Most healthy dogs tolerate high-quality natural chews well. However, dogs with sensitive stomachs may react to even natural protein sources. Start with small quantities to gauge individual tolerance. Always verify specific product suitability for your dog's age, size, and any known food sensitivities. Consult your veterinarian if your dog has a history of digestive issues.
Frequency depends on your dog's total daily caloric intake and activity level. Use protein-packed chews as part of your overall treat allowance (typically 10% of daily calories). Active summer dogs benefit from daily protein-packed chews as part of their nutrition plan, while less active dogs should receive them a few times weekly. Monitor weight and adjust accordingly.
Found this helpful? Share it!
Our team researches and tests hundreds of pet products every month so you don't have to. Every recommendation is based on real research: customer reviews, expert opinions, and value for money. Learn more about us →
This post contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you purchase through our links at no extra cost to you.
← Back to Best Pet Picks Daily| Retailer | Price Range | Shipping | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| Amazon | Check Current Price | Free (Prime) | View on Amazon → |
| Walmart | Check Site | Free over $35 | Search → |
| Target | Check Site | Free over $35 | Search → |
Prices may vary. Click through to each retailer for current pricing.
Free Download
The Complete Pet Product Guide 2026
Everything you need to know about choosing the best products for your pet — all in one free guide.
Get the Free Guide →